1. Introduction
Among various heavy elements mercury (II) ion is one of the most hazardous metal ion [1-5]. Pollution of the environment by this element is mainly due to the effluents form chemical industry, mining industry, combustion engine running on fossil fuel, incineration of solid waste etc. Mercury ion is soluble in water and very stable. Accumulation in human organs leads to devastating effect on central nervous system as well as failure of organ function such as kidney failure, brain damage. Maximum amount of mercury ion that is allowed in the drinking water is 2.0 parts per billion. Detection of mercury level in the effluents are very important for human health.
Various metal ion detection methods are inductively coupled plasma-mass spectroscopy, atomic absorption spectroscopy and mass spectroscopy. But there is limitation due to cost factor, time taken for measurement as well as labor intensive. Visual detection of metal ions is one of most convenient method [6-11]. This method is based on interaction of gold nanoparticle with the metal ion know as surface enhanced plasmonic resonance method. Gold nanoparticle are not stable for long time. So there is limitation for sensing of metal ion in real time by this method.
Solid state sensor based on gold nanoparticles enhance the stability as well as durability [12-17]. Different types of support used for solid state sensors are porous wood, glass, paper made up of cellulose. Nanofiber membranes made up of cellulose, chitosan, polycaprolactone and polysulfone are discussed in this review. Fig.1 Schematic presentation of the classification of the review.
2. Mercury sensors
Gold nanomaterials materials have limitation in application for chemical detection due to lower fluorescence efficiency as compared to quantum dots or organic dyes. Modification of nanoparticles with silicon oxide (SiO2) enhance the luminescent properties as well as generate higher quantum yield [18]. Metal organic framework (MOF) with nitrogen atoms have very good interaction with mercury ions resulting in better sensitivity [19].
2.1. Cellulose
In an attempt to develop a sensor that overcomes the biggest limitation of conventional solution-based Au nanomaterial sensors, which is stability, Fu et al. proposed the synthesis of solid-state membrane-based sensor for detection of Hg2+ [20]. Using porous cellulose nanofibrilatted (CNF) membrane as the platform for immobilization of gold nanoparticles (AuNPs) and sensing of Hg2+ ions, the AuNPs@CNF membrane showed a high fluorescent ability, where the lowest detection limit was determined to be 0.1 nM. The AuNPs@CNF sensor outshines other solution-based Au nanomaterial sensor when comparing their stabilities and AuNPs@CNF also exhibits great selectivity and facile detection method. Furthermore, substituting AuNPs for a different optical probe can potentially enable a detection of other metal ions, which suggests that CNF membrane can be used for a wide range of applications in real-site detections.
Porous cellulose acetate fiber is used as the support membrane for dithiothreitol capped with gold nanocluster (DDT.AuNC) which acts as fluorescent probe [21]. This is mainly used to detect Cu2+ ion, with a high selectivity for the specific metal ions. Selectivity of the sensor is checked in the presence of Zn (II), Cd (II) and Hg (II) ions. Response of this fluorescent probe is weak due to the absence of protection of the ligand that leads to the weak coordination with Cu (II) ion. The limit of detection of Cu (II) ion is 50 ppb and the maximum limit of presence of this ion is 1.3 ppm. This is the reason it is an effective sensor to check the level of mercury ion in the drinking water. The interaction between Cu (II) ion and DDT.AuNC is oxidative in nature that makes it very specific to copper (II) ion detection [Fig. 2~6].
2.2. Polycaprolactone
Senthamizhan group replaced DTT.AuNC@pCAF fluorescent probe with gold nanocluster (AuNC) for the sensing of Hg (II) ion [22]. The support for the probe is changed from porous cellulose acetate fiber to polycaprolactone nanofiber. The immobilized optical probe on the solid support enhances the lifetime of the sensor to over four months under room condition. Reducing the amount of bovine serum albumin (BSA) ligand from an excessive level to minimum improves the contact of AuNC fluorescent probe Hg (II) ion. It is one of the reasons for the high sensitivity of the probe towards Hg (II) ion even in the presence of Cu2+, Pb2+, Zn2+, Cd2+, Ni2+, Mn2+ ions. Another reason for the high sensitivity is the formation of amalgam between gold and mercury. It detection level of Hg (II) ion increased to parts per trillion (ppt) level [Fig.7~9].
To create a user-friendly, time-efficient and inexpensive method for Hg2+ detection, Tonsomboon et al. developed a cellulose acetate (CA)/polycaprolactone (PCL) membrane-based sensor that utilizes NF06, a novel organic dye, for a colorimetric detection of Hg2+ in water samples [23]. The membrane-based sensor was made by immobilizing NF06 onto the electrospun CA/PCL membrane through performing immersion methods twice. Composed of the combination of 2 fluorophores, Helicene (5H) and rhodamine 6 G thiohydrazide (thio-R6 GH), NF06 exhibits a remarkable sensitivity for detecting trace mercury ions. The membrane- based sensor that utilizes this novel optical probe has a limit of detection of 0.309 ppb (0.697 nM), suggesting that this sensor could potentially be used for various environmental and safety-related applications, including the safety evaluation of Hg2+ concentration in drinking water. With a facile synthesis method, cost-efficiency and excellent sensitivity, membrane-based sensor that utilizes NF06 shows great promises to enhance the current procedures for detecting Hg2+ in various water sources or consumer products.
2.3. Polyvinylalcohol
Using gluten, a plant protein, Mathew et al. developed a novel optical probe for the sensing of Hg2+ ions [24]. Processing gluten using hydrothermal carbonisation, graphene quantum dots (GQD) that emits blue-green light was successfully synthesized. Further treatment of GQD with gluten led to the synthesis of gold quantum clusters (AuQC) and incorporating this AuQC@GQD into electrospun polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) nanofibers finished the formation of a nanocomposite sensor for the colorimetric detection of Hg2+. The developed sensor showed a sensitivity ranging from 0.1 to 35.8 ppm and the facile detection method, in which it does not require any additional equipment upon determination of Hg2+ ions and allows an efficient on-site detection. Thus, the novel AuQC@GQD studied in this research is a green, facile and cost-efficient method for Hg2+ detection.
For an easy and fast on-site detection of Hg+ ions in real environmental sites, Senthamizhan et al. developed a nanocomposite membrane-based sensor that guarantees a decent sensitivity and an excellent durability in various conditions [25]. The biosensor was created by immobilizing gold nanoclusters (AuNC) in to electrospun polyvinyl alcohol nanofibers (NFM). AuNC*NFM exhibits a noticeably flexibility as well as durability, whose ability to perform fluorescent detection of Hg+ remains unaffected up to 100°C. The developed biosensor also has long-lasting storability. With its characteristic color upon contacting Hg+ ions, AuNC*NFM allows an easy, naked-eye colorimetric detection without requiring any further equipment, and shows a selective colorimetric change only to Hg+ when tested with other interfering ions. Lastly, AuNC*NFM probe was found to have a limit of detection around 1 ppb, and it is encouraged to continue further research to improve its sensitivity to be used as a primary biosensor for on-site detection of Hg+ in environmental water.
2.4. Chitosan
In this research, the benefits of using rhodamine B-chitosan moiety, which exhibits fluorescent properties that can be utilized for detection of Hg2+, was investigated by Horzum et al. [26]. Developed by the electrospinning of chitosan and rhodamine B hydrazide, the resulting electrospun fiber resulted in biodegradable, high-surface area sensor with enhanced fluorescence that can effectively detect Hg2+. Having a sensitivity as low as 10-9 mM when tested with water samples, the developed sensor also can be used in an on-off manner by using the spirolactam ring of rhodamine for the selective sensing of Hg2+. Thus, the developed sensor was posed as an excellent candidate, with environmentallyfriendly synthesis method, sensitivity, and practicability, for Hg2+ detection in environmental water.
2.5. Polysulfone
The excessive concentration of Hg+ ions in water has become one of the biggest environmental problems globally [27]. To create a tool that could contribute to alleviating this problem, Mukhopadhyay et al. developed a membrane-based sensor for the colorimetric detection of Hg+. Made by immobilizing Rhodamine B, a commonly used optical probe, on Polysulfone (PS) and sulfonated Polysulfone (SPS) membranes, the developed sensor exhibits a concentration-dependent sensitivity towards Hg+ ions, where increasing the concentration of Hg+ in water samples also increased the intensity of color change when tested with a range of Hg2+ concentration from 100 ppb to 100ppm. Having a facile synthesis method, where Rhodamine B was attached to membranes through a simple immersion method, and a fast naked-eye colorimetric sensing of Hg2+, the developed sensor works as a great candidate for detecting and quantifying the Hg2+ concentration in environmental settings.
2.6. Alternative
Upon contacting Ag+/Hg2+ ions, zein-protected fluorescent gold nanoclusters (Z-FGCs), the novel optical probe studied in this research, exhibits a notable change in its emission at 655 nm, while leaving the emission at 442 nm unaffected [28]. Utilizing this characteristics of zein, Duan et al. proposes the use of Z-FGCs as a new optical probe for detecting Ag+/Hg2+ ions. Fluorescent gold nanoclusters (FGCs) are generally created by reducing Au (III) in the presence of protecting ligand. In this research, Duan et al. used zein, a plant protein originating from corns, as the protecting and reducing agent when synthesizing FGCs and investigated the benefits of using zein in such procedure. Aside from the environmental-friendly, fast, and cost-efficient synthesis method, using zein also eases the separation of desired Z-FGCs from other, spectator molecules like HAuCl4 and NaOH, where Z-FGCs can easily be separated by adding acidic buffer, due to the inherent solubility of zein. Also, as zein adds the ability to form films to FGCs, the detection of Ag+/Hg2+ using FGCs could be simply visualized using Z-FGCs films, without requiring any further, complicated equipment or procedure. Therefore, on top of the high sensitivity of Z-FGCs as optical probes, using zein also poses multiple advantages that simplifies various aspects of Ag+/Hg2+ detection in water samples.
To form an effective and cost-efficient π-conjugated metal organic framework (MOFs) for a photoluminescence sensing of Hg2+, Razavi et al. synthesized a MOF with a structure of [Zn(OBA)-(DPT)0.5] using a tetrazine-functionalized spacer (TMU-34(-2H)) [29]. By putting the cation detection ability of TMU-34(-2H) into experiment, it was found that TMU-34(-2H) had the ability to accurately sense Hg2+ ions in both water and acetonitrile. Using double solvent sensing method (DSSM), in which the signal transduction curves of TMU-34(-2H) in water and acetonitrile were integrated to provide an enhanced sensitivity factor, could upgrade the performance of TMU-34(-2H) to demonstrate an ultrahigh sensitivity. Employing DSSM almost entirely eliminates any interfering, irrelevant responses while showing a higher sensitivity for Hg2+ ions. With a short detection time, excellent performance and selectivity, TMU-34(-2H) enables a superb optical detection of Hg2+ in various solutions [Fig. 10~12].
2.6.1. MOF
In this research, Wang et al. synthesized two metal organic frameworks (MOFs), whose sensing abilities were tested with various metals [30]. Both MOFs were hydrothermally created using BIPA ligand and the H2tfbdc ligand with Zn/Cd salts, the first MOF has the structure of [Zn(BIPA)(tfbdc)]n while the second MOF was found to be {Cd(BIPA)(tfbdc)(H2O)·DMF}n. Testing the synthesized MOFs with water samples that contain various metal ions proved that the first MOF, [Zn(BIPA)(tfbdc)]n, acted as a dual-responsive sensor that effectively detects both Fe3+ and Cr2O72- ions, while the second MOF, {Cd(BIPA)(tfbdc)(H2O)·DMF}n showed a selective sensitivity towards Hg2+ and Cr2O72- ions.
Yang et al. constructed a novel porphyrin-based luminescent metal-organic framework (LMOF) for the trace detection of Hg2+ ions in water [31]. The LMOF was synthesized by employing solvothermal reaction using Zr-O clusters and meso-tetra(4-carboxyphenyl) porphyrin (TCPP) ligands. The developed MOFs-based sensor showed a high fluorescent ability for detecting Hg2+ ions in a concentration-dependent manner, with a lowest limit of detection of 6 nM. Moreover, it guarantees a cost-efficient and fast – where the detection time was found to be around 2 minutes – sensing of the target metal ion in water samples. Demonstrating an intact performance in the presence of other interfering ions, the research poses the advantages of developed and utilizing porphyrin- based sensor for practical application of Hg2+ detection.
2.6.2. Polymer membrane
To construct an optical membrane for the detection of heavy metals, Kaoutit et al. utilized copolymers as the sensing platform for a colorimetric detection of Hg2+ [32]. The colorimetric assay of Hg2+ was simply done by immersing the membranes into water samples. The membranes revealed to display a concentrationdependent behaviour, where the intensity of color change varied depending on the concentration of Hg2+ in samples, and the lowest limit of detection was determined to be around 2 ppb (1 × 10-8 M). Analyzing digital pictures of the membranes also allowed for an approximation of the Hg2+ concentration in samples, which implied that the polymer-membrane investigated in this research could be applied for both detection and quantification of Hg2+. The application range of such versatile sensor, whose purpose is not only limited to determination of target metal and provides a fast and facile detection method, is wide, and it is found to be especially useful for safety test by measuring the concentration of Hg2+ ions in drinking water.
For a colorimetric detection of target metal ions using cycloruthenated complex, Wu et al. used a membranebased sensor that utilizes cyclometallated ruthenium complex (Ru1) as a sensing probe [33]. Exhibiting a color change from dark-red to yellow, the developed sensor was found to have a limit of detection as low as 0.053 μM in aqueous solution. Furthermore, applying the developed membrane-based cycloruthenated complex sensor into water samples that contain Hg2+ ions not only allowed for a colorimetric detection, but also removed a noticeable amount of Hg2+ ions in water solutions as the Hg2+ ions adsorbed onto the surface of the sensor. Thus, the sensor developed and investigated in this sensor shows potential to serve as a dual-purposed sensor for both the detection and filtration of Hg2+ contaminations in environmental fields.
3. Conclusions
Gold nanoparticle used for detection are not stable for long time along as well as problem of agglomeration. Alternative to this problem is to immobilization of nanomaterials on the solid substrate. Various kind of support used for this purpose are porous wood, glass and cellulose paper
Nanofiber membranes are excellent support due to high surface area. Synthetic polymer or biopolymers having plenty of functional groups are used for the fabrication of nanofiber membrane which can be very linked to various active molecules. In this review nanofiber membrane made up from cellulose, chitosan, polcaprolactone and polysufone are discussed. Nanofiber membrane with large surface area, good porosity and higher functional group enhance the ability of binding to ligands. Solid state sensor based on immobilized nanoparticles onto nanfiber membrane are much more stable and easily to handle then solution state sensors.